End of Life

Will Euthanasia in the US Follow Canada’s Trajectory?

As an advocate for the right to life, I want to see a society that cherishes and protects its most vulnerable members, ensuring that every person has the opportunity to fulfill their potential. No person should be killed because someone believes they are inconvenient or a burden.  

It is disturbing that acceptance of “assisted suicide” has only grown in recent years. In less than a decade, the global conversation surrounding this topic has shifted from an end to great suffering for the terminally ill to a standard medical offering for a growing list of vulnerable populations. While its proponents have always claimed that assisted suicide is an act of mercy, it has increasingly revealed itself to be a functional tool that threatens the sick, the disabled, the poor, and the mentally ill. When we examine the trajectory of state-sanctioned deaths in Canada’s Medical Assistance in Dying program, for example, it becomes clear that the devaluing of human life will only grow worse under MAID than it already is.  

The initial pitch for euthanasia promised to relieve the physical agony of those on the brink of death. However, as Bobby Schindler, who began advocating for the medically vulnerable after his sister, Terri Schiavo, was starved and dehydrated to death in 2005, says, “This is the natural progression when society permits the destruction of innocent life in the womb: The same utilitarian approach applied to our vulnerable unborn brothers and sisters will increasingly be applied after birth.”  

When society hardens its heart to preborn human beings and when it begins to classify whose lives are worth living based on productivity or perceived quality, it mirrors the darkest chapters of history, such as in Nazi Germany.  

I don’t use this comparison lightly. The Aktion T4 program in Nazi Germany began with physicians and bureaucrats, who framed the systematic killing of a quarter million of the disabled and medically fragile as a “mercy death” for those deemed “unworthy of life.” Today, we see a disturbing echo of this moral reasoning. When the state provides the means for death based on a doctor’s assessment of a “grievous and irremediable” condition, it affirms the idea that a life with a disability or chronic illness is of lesser value. 

The Canadian warning 

Canada’s Medical Assistance in Dying program serves as a grim case study of how quickly safeguards can erode. Between its legalization in 2016 and 2024, 76,475 people were euthanized within its guidelines. While the public was assured that this would be an exceptional measure for the dying, it has instead become routine.  

In 2021, the program dropped the requirement for “reasonable foreseeability of natural death” and expanded eligibility to include people with chronic illnesses and disabilities. The criteria continue to loosen, giving doctors authority to choose death for their patients based on their own assumptions of the value of life.  

The tragic case of Kiano Vafaeian highlights these loose criteria. At just 26 years old, Vafaeian—who was blind and had type 1 diabetes and mental struggles—was euthanized against his family’s wishes in December 2025. His family now argues that the system failed him and has accused the country’s laws of “killing the disabled and vulnerable” who are struggling with depression rather than a terminal diagnosis.  

Additionally, there are at least 428 cases of noncompliant euthanasia deaths, according to the chief coroner of Ontario.  

When the solution to the challenges of disability or mental health is a lethal injection, the medical establishment has fully abandoned its oath to “do no harm”—if it ever took one in the first place.  

The poverty of choice 

Perhaps the most alarming development is the use of social factors as drivers for assisted suicide. Reports from the Office of the Chief Coroner of Ontario have highlighted cases where death was either offered to or chosen by various people not because of physical pain, but because of homelessness, fear, and isolation. One man sought euthanasia because he was lonely; another sought it to avoid the indignity of a lack of social support. 

This is the “slippery slope” in action. When assisted suicide is an option, it becomes the cheapest “treatment” for complex social problems. For the poor and marginalized, the “right to die” can quickly transform into a “duty to die” to relieve the burden on the state or the healthcare system. The Ontario coroner’s report explicitly warned that underprivileged persons are particularly vulnerable to “coercion or undue influence” regarding MAID, which could suggest that social neglect is “solved” with state-sanctioned death. 

Social pressure also comes from global authorities who push utilitarian ideologies, such as climate activism, which treats population growth as a crisis. When researchers argue that having children is bad for the climate and advocate for aggressive family planning in order to lower fertility, they reinforce a worldview where human beings are seen as carbon-emitting liabilities rather than as individuals with inherent dignity given by God.  

A call for protection 

As of September 2026, 13 US states and the District of Columbia have decriminalized assisted suicide. While these states currently maintain safeguards, history and global experience suggest that these boundaries are rarely as robust or permanent as promised. Once a society begins accepting the notion that some circumstances justify a doctor intentionally ending a patient’s life, the definition of who “qualifies” inevitably expands. 

True compassion and mercy do not lie in providing a lethal dose of poison to a lonely man, an ill and suffering woman, or a depressed youth. It lies in addressing the root causes of their pain: improving palliative care, expanding mental health support, and ensuring that no one feels they must choose death because they lack a home or a community.  

To protect the most vulnerable among us, we must reject the utilitarian classification of human life and reaffirm the truth that every person is worthy of protection, from creation to death. Christians especially must speak out to remind our world that every human being is created in the image of God and that every person, regardless of his circumstances, has a life worth living.

Facebook Comments

About the author

Christine Rhyner

Christine Rhyner is a strong advocate for the right to life and has published numerous articles on this topic and related issues. When not writing, she enjoys scrapbooking, the beach, and spending time with family. Her latest book, The Adopted Son Who Almost Wasn’t, was released on November 9, 2026, World Adoption Day.